Sunday, July 29, 2012

The Phenomenon of the Absurd





He was condemned for life to ceaselessly roll a rock to the top of a mountain, whence the stone would fall back of its own weight and he would start back to reach the bottom of the mountain to set on his task again
Three humans reached hell and were conducted into a room. They sat for long awaiting the torturer, but to their bewilderment the room was finally locked from outside and they realized that with just the three of them in the room they were to torture each other.
Two men meet on a park bench in New York City's Central Park. Jerry is desperate to have a meaningful conversation with another human being. He intrudes on Peter's peaceful state by interrogating him and forcing him to listen to stories from his life. The final connection is established when Jerry impales himself on the knife held in Peter’s hand.
Stories with psychological and philosophical inflections written and performed on stage perplexed audiences with their absurd content and intent. Theatre of the absurd was born after World War 2 but the writings and the philosophy existed much before the time and came to be known as existential ism. The main proponents of the philosophy being Kierkegaard, Albert Camus, Jean Paul Sartre and Friedrich Nietzsche.
What is absurdity? It exists in a juxtaposition. Man wants unity, closure and definitive answers to his role in the universe. The mute and silent universe goes about its work without providing him any concrete solutions. As such, the absurd does not exist either in man or in the universe, but in the confrontation between the two. If we try to reconcile the conflict between our need for answers and the world's silence we will be evading the absurd rather than confronting it. Camus characterizes our confrontation with the absurd with an absence of hope, continual rejection, and conscious dissatisfaction. Living with this conflict is neither pleasant nor easy, but trying to overcome the conflict does not answer so much as it negates the problem of the absurd.
I watched the life and times of Claude Achille Debussy to mark his Sesquicentennial , last weekend  at Fundasco Oriente hosted by none other than Dr Luis Diaz. Debussy lived when impressionism was at its peak and his musical scores are inspired equally by poets, writers and artists. No doubt when man became aware of his absurdity, he gave it expression through various mediums of arts, writing and philosophy. 
Kierkegaard’s work ‘Fear and Trembling’ and Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s ‘Crime and Punishment’ and many others reconcile the tension making the "leap of faith" into God, where they identify the irrational with faith and with God and redemption of man through acceptance and grace. But Camus and Nietzsche are interested in whether we can live with the feeling of absurdity, not whether we can overcome it. Milan Kundera’s ‘The Unbearable Lightness of Being’ compares and contrasts light and heavy characters. The former beings live a full life indulging their senses. Self-centeredness, detachment and the present moment to be explored and lived to its hilt form their guiding principle in life. They are not guided by regret, sin, guilt or an afterlife. The latter are bound by duty, honor and truth and their karma. The ultimate climax nonetheless, does not render any one character contented and happy with their choices.
The Theatre of the Absurd is fallout of the above philosophy and the repercussions of the The World Wars – an artistic expression akin to Marcel Duchamp’s controversial works and T.S Eliot’s ‘The Wasteland’. The Theatre of the Absurd shows the failure of man without recommending a solution. The plays vary in their execution and presentation but the common thread that ties them together is parody, with tragic and abysmal scenes; characters caught in hopeless situations performing repetitive meaningless actions. Playwrights commonly associated with the Theatre of the Absurd include Samuel Beckett, Jean Genet, Harold Pinter and Edward Albee to name a few.
Kafkaesque, a repertoire of the absurd touched its zenith with the story ‘The Metamorphosis’. An extraordinary transformation of the protagonist Gregor Samsa into a giant insect is relayed in a mundane banal tone highlighting the absurd and chaotic in an everyday home with the kitsch of huge debts and themes of alienation and isolation. The evolving feelings of love and care juxtaposed with animal yearnings of food and shelter in Gregor, the insect (whose very sight and habits disconnect him from the family he so much cared for) deliver him in the end. Horrified by his appearance and transition from a bread winner to a grotesque burden and a liability his family distances itself from him and his death releases the family to better days. In a way the story questions the consciousness of humans versus the animal world which is devoid of it. 
Nietzsche’s ‘Genealogy of Morality’ questions the birth of the concepts of ‘Good and Evil’. Man’s search for meaning is an exercise in futility because life is inherently meaningless and truth is only subjective. He fosters the concept of self actualization; and terms it the phenomenon of the OVERMAN. When man reined in his animal instincts and harnessed his energy into civilizations, discoveries and science; that was his first step towards self overcoming. Nihilism which gripped mankind with advancing science can be neutralized if man turns inwards and fights the greatest of battles with his will power and questions his own assumptions, prejudices and beliefs. The overman loves life warts and all; indulging in life affirming activities.
Lets talk something more about the aforementioned artist Marcel Duchamp and the Dadaist movement in modern art history. The submission of an exhibit titled "Fountain", a so called readymade inverted urinal to the Society of Independent Artists, caused waves in the artistic world. Dadaism appeared to reject logic and embrace chaos and irrationality. It countered everything that art had stood for all these years. It was not art but anti art ; It ignored aesthetics and offended and shocked the viewer rather than please the sensibilities. A strong and revolutionary statement of the perception of the times(world war 1).  The Dadaists parleyed into surrealism with continuing political instability and the burgeoning second global war, indicative of a total collapse of human civilization. Surrealists like Salvador Dali and Max Ernst attempted to mirror the subconscious mind the bedrock of anxieties, complexes, dreams and fantasies to address the unease they felt about the world's uncertainties. They were interested in exposing the complex and repressed inner worlds of sexuality, desire, and violence.
The treatise on absurdity negates all human effort to find rationality and order in their lives. However, because we have difficulty accepting this notion, we constantly attempt to identify or create rational structure and meaning in our lives. One irrevocable truth stares us in the face constantly; that which takes birth has to die; but we spend our entire lives resisting it. It is so easy to say LET GO; but so difficult to bring it into practice. Live the ambiguity wherein lies the truth and ephemeral beauty of life!
True to an absurd play which is cyclic at most times, I take you back to the three stories at the beginning from where we started the narrative. The reader if intrigued by the situational paradox that the stories open up, can set on a trail to discover their sources wherein your journey to the ABSURD will begin afresh. Welcome to the whirlpool; The Phenomenon of the Absurd!


Jugneeta.susan@gmail.com – an academician, who conducts book reading workshops on classics, fiction and non-fiction books


                                                

Saturday, July 28, 2012

Feisty Heroines of Literature



Feisty Heroines of Literature

 ‘Alice in Wonderland’ directed by Tim Burton did not bag laurels just for the colorful portrayal of the Mad Hatter, but a complete reworking of the character of ALICE. A well mannered, soft spoken, delicate darling Alice made it to the gumption list of the contemporary heroines. She takes on the evil queen in a fight and refuses to marry the prince. Manjula Padmnabhan’s ‘Unprincess’ is a maverick girl who takes on her own battles and knows her mind. A far cry from the Marys and and Beths of the Enid Blyton fame who were docile, gentle and well mannered. Heroines of the yesteryears were about sacrifice, eternal love and duty. They were not supposed to flirt, throw a tantrum to acquire their heart’s desire or eye their friend’s suitor. Even if such human feelings surfaced in them they were to camouflage their true spirit under a garb of politeness and sweetness. No doubt women are always scheming and plotting – cause they could never be forthright and open about themselves and their desires. Certainly not supposed to be assertive, let the whole world know whom they loved and be selfish and ruthless in pursuit of their goals in life. We would have heavily frowned upon such heroines and we did exactly that down the ages. Madame Bovary, Hester Prynne, and Scarlet o’ Hara were read with censure rather than admiration and sympathy. But now the tables have turned and when we read Scarlet O ‘ Hara we see her as a brave woman who survives the civil war with hard work and a no nonsense attitude to the whole scene of war. We view her more realistically and admit that the reason Rhett Butler is attracted to her in the first place is because of her forthright attitude and outspokenness. A force to reckon with,   who cooked and plotted scenes and was relentless in her love pursuits but that is what makes her human and not just a doll with plastic well- rehearsed answers and expectations.
‘Well behaved women do not make history’ said Laurel Thatcher Ulrich. Creations of writing and imagination, literature has created legendary heroines who in retrospect rank high on the list of FIESTY HEROINES. Who are these heroines who compete for a place in the elite list? They don’t need to wrestle with stalkers, or kick sick men in their asses,  they just need to conform to being smart, confident, gutsy, vivacious, articulate and very clear to know their minds and make unhindered choices; female protagonists, whom we have read and who have stepped out of print and become our close companions and confidantes.
Shakespeare’s Cleopatra has been objectified, declared a temptress a “whore”, an enchantress who made Antony “the noble ruin of her magic.” This threat has much to do with Cleopatra’s beauty and expressive sexuality.  Cleopatra is self-involved, a narcissist. The dichotomy of a manipulative seductress versus an able leader will always stay with her image as 19th century artists painted her with the asp applied to her breast rather than the arm where it bit her – clearly indicating the fact that she was more an object of desire than a strong woman   ; nevertheless, her charisma, strength, and indomitable will makes her one of Shakespeare’s strongest, most awe-inspiring female characters.
Hester Prynne in ‘The Scarlet Letter’ wears the scarlet letter on her bosom with gumption and lives with her daughter in the same place that ostracized her. She also never breathes out the name of the father of her child. Shamed and alienated from the rest of the community, Hester becomes contemplative. She speculates on human nature, social control, and larger moral questions. Hester’s tribulations also lead her to be stoic and a freethinker.
Elizabeth Bennet is never intimidated in ‘Pride and Prejudice’. Jane Austen thought her ‘as delightful a character as ever appeared in print’; a woman who is delightful for reasons other than those of beauty alone. She is characterized by wit, independence and a courageous ability to admit her mistakes. She wants to be seen as a rational and autonomous human being in the same way as men are. She tells Mr Collin as much.
Jo March, the rebel and tomboy of ‘Little Women,’ beseechingly asks her mother why she cannot be content to sew, cook and look after babies like her sisters. The restlessness and adventurous spirit drives her to travel and finally she falls in love with her writing and the professor. Her struggle to blend family life and responsibilities with a creative profession could be a precursor to the choices women make today.
Catherine’s wildness in ‘Wuthering Heights’ is the rejection of her gender identity as defined by a bourgeois society. The heliographic on the walls of her room at Wuthering Heights is the symbolic remnant of her struggle – Catherine Earnshaw, Catherine Heathcliff and then again Catherine Linton. Her practicality makes her choose to be a lady over her wild passion for Heathcliff, which is her real self. Catherine is a women’s anguished voice which revolts; a haunting presence, always to remind of that which is denied to her – of what she actually wanted to be.
 In Anna Karenina the theme is one of adultery, a romance which shakes the foundation of a society steeped in hypocrisy. Anna is unforgettable for her refusal to observe the proprieties exacted in such a liaison  - remember she adamantly argues with Vronsky and goes and attends the opera in her regal attire.
Growing up I admired  Anne Shirley of Green Gables – the red head with a definite mind of her own. She questions religious faith and hypocritical rituals. Her pride hath a fall, but she is quick to redeem herself. If now we are talking of young spunky girls, not to mention Pippi Longstocking would be sacrilege. The most independent of characters, battles day to day encounters with superhuman strength. And Matilda  of Roald Dhal fame , a child prodigy – who has devoured each and every book in the adult section before she is ten. 
If we were to shift the narrative from fictional to real life women who live in our societies and create such colossal feminine characters then Maya Angelo, Alice Walker, Anita Desai would take the lead. Anita Desai is unique in portraying a wide gamut of Indian women in her novels. What really struck me was that in one of her interviews, she candidly admitted that she loved her writing passion and would yearn for time to herself away from her responsibilities of family life and children – to return to her first love – WRITING ; very akin to Virginia Woolf’s – a room of one’s own.
If you are attracted to some people and characters, it is an indication of the fact that you harbor some of their characteristics and aspire to be even more like them. Well, if that holds true and you admire these maverick heroines, definitely emulate some of them and live up your life!

Saturday, July 14, 2012

Classical Encounters



                                                  Classical Encounters
Which book are you reading these days, is a question I often ask people when I meet them. Sharing stories and experiences connects us to people and the cliché that books are our best friends holds true. Our super consciousness is satiated when we read, observe, reflect and thus evolve. Books open many doors into the vast suspended mystery of the world through varied experiences, myriad perceptions and diverse mindsets of writers who give it shape and form. Reflection and brainstorming distills the truth about an ambiguous, bewildering and breathing cosmos.
What do we learn when we read in the conventional manner? Of course we learn about books and authors. But it is the distilled essence of the subject, the story, or the character which remains with us over extended periods of time. The corpus of ideas, assumptions and attitudes that we pick up while reading may not be formally stated even by ourselves, but in a sense is all the more real, being pervasive yet invisible. Good literature percolates into the innermost recesses of our mind through the subtlest trajectory, or we would be wary of it. As Keats said, ‘we distrust literature which has a palpable design upon us,’ that is literature which too obviously wants to convert us or influence our views.
Recorded  history is the story of mankind on earth. Classics from Homer’s ‘Odyssey’, Kalidasa’s ‘Recognition of Shakuntala’, Shakespeare’s ‘Othello’,  ‘The Qissa of Heer Ranjha’ by Waris Shah to contemporary literature portray the tales of man which are ever repetitive. These great classics live on and never die, as human nature and behavioral patterns recur again and again. Such writing is not for an age but for all times; news which stays news (Ezra Pound’s definition of literature)

This column invites you to delve into your reading corpus and dwell on most desirable characters which left an indelible mark in the cauldrons of your mind :                                                                                                                                                             Fictional characters, which   assume a larger than life force and stay with us for all our lives, increasing our perceptions and opening doors to the intricate human psyche; and thereby, aiding us in the in- depth and exploratory understanding of ourselves.

 I simply cannot get over these men and women who have been constant companions in my journey through life and I revisit them with great pleasure in their original settings, that is, in the books where I encountered them first. Each meeting is new and fresh – unencumbered by the previous interlude; maybe an indication of the fact that as I grow, I evolve and my understanding of the character is greater and wholesome; a novelty which never tires to amaze me; a timeless significance of great writing perhaps.

Anne - Anne of Green Gables
Anne with an ‘e’ is spunky and has the wildest of imaginations. So much so that she coins the most innovative and interesting names for insipid and fabulous places alike.  She is a red-haired, freckle-faced orphan who faces the world with absolutely nothing but the sheer force of her personality. I love her. The always eloquent Anne opines, “It’s so easy to be wicked without knowing it.” The book ends with the line “God’s in his heaven, all’s right with the world,” inspires great faith in me.

PipGreat Expectation
Philip Pirrip (Pip), gripped me at an early age. Like him, I had hopes of escaping the loving, but limited, quotidian world that surrounded me. And, like Pip, I learnt to be ashamed of those good people that I loved and then bitterly ashamed of that shame.
Joe Gargery
The modest, sweet Joe Gargery in great Expectation brings out the best in you. The big E- EGO that we live with has no part to play in his life. He motivates and at the same time humbles me to LOVE.
Becky Sharp – Vanity Fair
Her impoverished childhood propels her to snare the richest of men in matrimony. Her character lives an obsession driven by lack which she wants to fulfill at the cost of true love.
Jane Eyre – Jane Eyre
The governess at Thornfield Hall working for the deliciously dark Mr Rochester , she never lets her societal position or gender stand in her way. The caring meticulous hardworking Jane may appear to be plain, but the simmering passionate sexuality underneath makes her a potent mix preying perpetually on the heroes sensibilities. Looks can be highly deceptive and fatal!
Holden Caulfield – Cather in the Rye
Filled with a penetrating nothingness he sees the world as stated in the most famous controversial line of the book,:”If you had a million years to do it in, you couldn’t rub out even half the ‘suck you’ signs in the world.” A line instead of being obscene itself is directed against  obscenity. The things he finds repulsive are the things he calls phony; and the phoniness in every instance is the absence of love, and often, the substitution of pretence for love. He rages against a false society of convention and immortality and ends with the acceptance and love as saving grace.
Bakha – Untouchable
The grief and misery we inflict on living people with our belief systems and rigid mindsets.
The Tramps (Vladimir and Estragon) –Waiting for Godot,
The tramps and the absurd play lived with me long after….The senselessness of the human condition to which we impart such great importance. The wonder, incomprehension and and at times the despair at the meaninglessness of life……………
Celie – The Color Purple
Her evolvement  from a non - entity and just a hand in the household ; to a thinking woman who questions her role in her marriage and her position in society
Swami –Swami and Friends
His mind goes into a puddle when he is  presented with a mathematics question about the cost of mangoes. The narration of the episode in the book helped me identify with Swami so much as student. I felt liberated from the feeling that the comprehension of numbers wasn’t everyone’s game and there was no need to feel incapacitated because of it.
Scarlet O’Hara – Gone with the Wind
Scarlet O'Hara is maddening. She's beautiful, passionate, and fiery. She's strong-willed, an idiot, and irritating as hell. Who hasn't fallen for such a woman?
Rhett Butler 
He spoiled me for life, a fantasy so hard to beget in real life -  witty, courageous, tender, patient, indulging……

The list is inexhaustible. We shall keep talking about them and more in the writings in this column in the editions to come. These characters have changed your life course, helped you make your choices, or awakened you to new thoughts. Send us your favorites. The best ones will be printed in the forthcoming issues. Happy reflections!